🔗 Share this article

Per newly revealed information from Embark Studios, Arc Raiders appears to utilize generative systems for creating some voice lines. This news is strikingly similar to the debate that arose with the developer's previous success, The Finals.

Title Introduction

Released on October 30 for Sony's console, PC, and Xbox Series X, Arc Raiders is marketed as a easier entry point to the competitive survival genre. In contrast with established behemoths like Escape from Tarkov, it aims to offer a welcoming gameplay. The title has mostly received positive feedback, maintaining a highly favorable score on Steam based on over 8,000 gamer feedback.

AI Disclosure

On the game's official Steam page, a notice regarding computer-assisted production draws comparisons: In the production phase, we might apply algorithmic and intelligent technologies to support material generation. In every instance, the resulting game showcases the creativity and vision of our development team."

Past Issue

The Finals, a successful multiplayer first-person shooter known for its smooth gunplay and dynamic battlefields, faced criticism for its use of AI prior to its official launch. During its October 2023 open beta, the project's audio lead disclosed in a online discussion that the development team had used artificial intelligence systems for developing vocal tracks. This announcement prompted immediate negative reaction from industry talent and game developers, who argued that AI-generated voices were of notably lower quality compared to actor deliveries and that such methods could eliminate acting roles.

Company Position

Addressing concerns, the development team stated that they had contracted experienced performers to create initial dialogue for The Finals, but supplemented these with TTS technology to create extra lines based on those initial performances. The developer's reasoning centered on the production efficiency obtained via this approach.

Latest Developments

About Arc Raiders, the game's design director commented that the release "in no way uses artificial intelligence creation whatsoever," though he declined to elaborate on the precise meaning of the Steam disclosure. He did acknowledge, however, that the equivalent speech tools used for The Finals was also incorporated in Arc Raiders.

"We use a combination of recorded voice audio and content created through text-to-speech technology in our releases, according to the situation," explained a company spokesperson. In certain cases, recording real scenes where actors get together — allowing character chemistry and drama to influence the result — is something that contributes richness to our game worlds that AI cannot replicate. In other instances, notably when it concerns contextual in-game action call-outs, text-to-speech enables us to have customized dialogue where we otherwise wouldn't such as due to development pace."

Gamer Feedback

Early feedback to the incorporation of generative tools in Arc Raiders has been somewhat nuanced, notably in the launch window. Certain gamers have voiced significant concerns.

• Synthetic speech represents a stain on an generally excellent experience," stated one user in a community thread.
• "I hate that they implemented it in The Finals and am disappointed to hear they did it again for this game," responded another.
• The result was quickly detectable in the vocal lines for a specific character," noted a different user.

That said, some users have expressed a more tolerant stance.

• I don't care, they paid voice actors and applied it appropriately," commented one online participant.
• This represents the most responsible as it gets these days, unfortunately," added another.

The continuing debate surrounding technology adoption in game development looks prepared to persist as companies balance creative efficiency with artistic integrity and moral concerns.